In alkyl groups, the size of the inductive
effect has the following order:
This is to be expected from our previous discussion of the inductive
effect. However, the order is not the same when these groups are
attached to an unsaturated system (e.g. double bond, or benzene).
The reason for this disturbance of the order is that there is another
effect at work, which allows the alkyl groups to donate electrons.
This is known as hyperconjugation.
This is similar to the mesomeric effect. Obviously,
the proton which is ejected in the scheme above should not be considered
as being a loose proton. It is still loosely associated with
the parent molecule. A reversal of the inductive electron
donating order can be explained as being due to the presence of
hydrogen atoms attached to the carbon adjacent to the unsaturated
system. e.g.:
| CH3 |
> |
MeCH2 |
> |
Me2CH |
> |
Me3C |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
Clearly, if this is the case, the greatest effect
will be with CH3, and the least (i.e. none) with CMe3.
|